ORIGINAL: mez
I voted against. I echo GMMAT's assesment on the issue. Who am I to tell someone how they can or can't enjoy deer hunting so I will have a chance at a bigger deer. Shoot whatever makes you happy.
If big racks are that important to you there are plenty of avenues to shoot a wallhanger without telling someone else what to shoot.
Exactly why I voted against them, well said Mez.
If you're too lazy to hunt harder or smarter antler restrictions won't help you either, nor will they create a booner behind every tree, all they really do is reduce choice for everyone to pacify an antler obsessed few.