Huntmup, don' t feel bad. These are your honest feelings as best I can tell. I don' t know you personaly, and I can' t speak for your motives for starting this debate. I get the feeling you had a bad experience with the heads and you wanted to at least make people aware of what happend to you. You layed out your case, and presented yourself in a polite manor. I do not question or doubt your findings. I can only say that in my testing ( which we all know is not real world field conditions) I have not found the problems you have. I have spoken to 10 or so people that have used the heads on game, all with good results. Of course every setup is differnt as is every shot. You had some problems, others have not. This debate can be about any head. Infact a while back we had some discussion about Muzzy heads. Most love them, but a few hated them, all for there own reasons. I would much rather you post about your results than to keep quiet. Things like this make me question my findings and search deeper to find out what I can do to improve my reports and add to the debate.
I have spoken with Gary several times via email. He also seems very sincere and believes in his products. I don' t blame or condem him one bit for defending his broadheads. That fact that I would tend to agree with him on this matter doesn' t mean that your position is wrong. You layed your case out very well. It will be up to the individual bowhunter to buy a pack of heads and test them personaly, as well as read this debate in order to decide if the slick tricks are for them.