RE: Mature Buck or old Gobbler?
A MATURE buck (4+.... or even 5+) is a hard thing to kill my part of the world.
That said... a two year old turkey will stir my blood as much as a big buck will.... at least up til the shot... deer don't effect me until after the shot.. turkeys effect me up until the shot.
If I had to give one up... I'd never miss deer hunting though...