It could go either way in my opinion. Some people have a nack for big bucks. I feel like anyone who has a clue about deer could get on deer if they frequent a certain propery quickly. Getting a good buck is a different story. I allow one friend to hunt one of my properties with me. I have known him for years and until he started hunting my property 5 years ago, his largest buck was about a 100 inch 8 point. He started hunting my property with me, (we both use the same stands, he always gives me first pick of stand) and he consistantly shoots more and bigger bucks than i do. He just has the "luck", or knowledge to be in the right stand at the right time. Since he has hunted his property, he has shot his 7 largest bucks with the last buck being a 124" 8 point. When we hunt different properties i usually out produce him. I dont understand it, but its the way it is.