Update:
I had two little ding marks in my riser shelf, so I moved the rest back to the farthest hole, in an attempt to have the end of the prongs just before the beginning of the shelf... but it didn't quite work, so now I have 4 little ding marks on my shelf.
Before I left the office, I stopped by a few classrooms on the way out and filled a little baggy with chalk dust, and when I got home, I applied the dust to the fletchings on one of my arrows. I shot it a good 5 or six times and I couldn't detect any scrapes or marks in the chalk that would indicate fletching contact, so I feel confident that I can time my rest correctly! I'm not about to adjust my nock at all since it was so nicely put on by the nice guys at Huntersfriend.com, and since I tried warming my teflon covers in hot tap water with the hopes of making them compliant enough to slide onto the prongs, but with no luck, I decided to take the whammy off until I get some prongs that I'm happy with, and that won't smack against my shelf.

A question about the Burger Button hole... Is this the hole into which I bolted my rest from the other side? And is this the magic location where the arrow rests on the perfect bow set up, or would I just move my nock point up if I couldn't get the rest to stop banging into the shelf from this location and had to raise the vertical position of the rest?

I was busy all day today, so I didn't contact SpotHogg about replacement prongs. I did, however put my hostage back on and piled 3 arrows together from across my bedroom (17 feet, I measured ) and am unable to pull them out! This was a huge confidence booster that I am able to change rests myself without needing an archery pro to hold my hand the whole time! My makeshift target is much more difficult to remove arrows from than the nice foam targets at the proshop! I also tightened my limbs down from 65 to the full 70 (i'm guessing its 70 exactly) and now my bow feels smoother! It also shot a bit more quietly too! I am wondering if I'd have an easier time keeping the arrow on the Whammy with my easier, heavier draw weight...

*droptine, those hunter implants look awesome... very quiet I bet! I'll have to check if BassPro carries them the next time I go up there to spend the rest of my $$$