It sounds to me like you may have a little different anchor position than most of us. Whatever works. But, all these sights are moveable. At 250 I' d say go with at least 2 pins. I prefer precise aiming points. I know a lot of people use one pin, but there' s nothing like not having to aim over or low. At 250 fps you would have to have a lot of hold off to be on target. My goal is to hit a particular hair or spot, not be in the area. Then, the only hold off I may have is for the nervous state of the deer.