ORIGINAL: Centaur 1
I'm not suggesting that any of them are bad, I just believe that they all can't be good for all situations. You can kill both pronghorns and grizzly bears with a 30-06, but you wouldn't even dream of shooting a grizzly with a 125 grain thin jacket bullet or take a 400 yard shot at an antelope with a 220 grain round nose. We have no way judging broadhead performance other than guessing.
I go by whats worked for me and what I've seen my BH do, there's no guessing for me as i've used the same BH for 13 years now and know exactly what it will do. There's no need to switch up if there doing there job. I understand where your coming from though Centaur.
You made some good points in your previous post.