I believe consistently taking P&Y class deer equals hunter ability, reference back to the "are you jeoulous of a first timer scoring a big buck thread". That is a fact and it happens every year where a newbie smokes a big boy. Now show me a hunter with several P&Y deer and I will assure you hunter ability had something to do with it. I know you need the luck factor but I firmly believe that as your number of big deer killed go up your luck factor (while still existing) is not as heavily relied on.