There is no perfect stand for all hunting situations, i own 2 tree lounges. I use them pretty much everytime i go hunting during gun season. they are without a doubt the safest most comfortable stand you can own. Yes they are heavier than some other models out there, but they also pack together much more compact than most other portable stands. If you are making alot of noise while packing the stand, you arent taking the time to pack it right, it doesnt make any clanging noises if its packed right. I can put it on the tree and be hunting just as fast as my summit razor, and just as quiet. Yes i own a summit razor, i use it during bow season becausei dont like bowhunting from my tree lounge. But if for some reason i was forced to make a decision and could only have 1 climber, I would definatly have to keep my lounge!