Dude first of all... You guys should of just told this guy that you and your father would look for the deer and just sent him back to the club house!!! Especially after knowing this guys track record...If this story is in fact true... Your father should of told this guy he was a F ing A hole and that there is no way on gods green earth that he was going to give this buck to him... And if he didn't like it I would of kicked his A right there on the spot... Them I would of talked to someone to get him out off the club... If this club backed this A hole... I would start looking for another club... Or do like i do and just hunt public land