Tough call Rob. I hate to say it, but I think the story is wrong, looks to me like a gun kill.

BUT. It just looks that way to me, I wasnt there, and it cant be proved beyond a "reasonable doubt". I'm gonna vote to let it STAY, It will be on his conscience if he truely did lie about his buck and decieved his friends.

And I'm sorry this had to happen leathalconnection, its a great deer no matter what weapon was used, and you should be very proud. (after all, I've been skunked this year)

-Team 36 Captain