I have had great luck using scents but I don't use stuff bought at the big box stores for the most part. I figure every deer in PA or anywhere else has smelled Tinks and knows something is just not right. Might fool a young buck or even does to come in and check it out but anything else is heading the other way.

Tinks must have a million deer to sell as much "urine" as they do. OR.. something is not quite right.