Now, with the good buck doe ratio and low hunting pressurewe have where i hunt, i would take the antlers hands down. I have had amazing success with them in the last 2-3 years...before that, when the buck:doe ratio was worse, responses were rare. I have only had onebuck of any kind actually come into a grunt call, ever, that I can recall...but that was the12 pointi took last weekend so go figure. Even then he did not respond to me untill I snort wheezed at him with my mouth...then he responded to grunts too.

Honestly though, accessories are overrated i think. they work a portion of the time but i try not to depend on them as my 'main' plan.