I understand the situation you are in. I just purchased a new Mathews Legacy.
I had shot the same Hoyt for the past 15 yrs and finally decided to purchase a new bow.
There are many quality bows on the market today and all have their positives. I went to my local pro shop and they sell PSE, High Country, and Mathews. He did not try to persuade me to any one bow. What he did do was let me shoot several different bows and make my own decision. The reason I chose Mathews was because of the way it felt and shot. It just felt comfortable in my hands. Also, I wanted to purchase the bow from a local dealer because of service, set-up, and future adjustments.

Dont let hype or marketing persuade you in your decision. Shoot several bows and when you find the right one you will know it.