I'm guessing 2.5 on the top photo. Look at his neck. I KNOW they fill out a lot after their summer coats go.....and I can appreciate where you're hunting. This is just my guess (and reasoning).

If that's a doe, beside him.....and not a BB....he COULD be 1.5 based on his body size. If he is....he's an EXCEPTIONAL 1.5 yr old.

This from a field judging newbie.....lol.