Looking at the headgearhe doesn't look that old, but then looking at the depth of his chest slightly bigger belly, etc......and then body size compared to the mature doe he is next to he may be older than I think.
I suspect this picture is of an old friend that many of you may recognize from 2x years ago. If you look at the closeup of him, you can see he is a halfrack........[8D]. Antler wise he isn't big however he may be 3.5 or better this year and just never grew impressive headgear because of previous injuries.
How old you you think this guy is? Do you think the bottom two pictures are of the same deer?
This year:
Zoomed in:
2005 pictures of a buck I think may be him: