I myself have been a PSE man until recently. A few friends of mine have been shooting/hunting with Mathews for some time now and love them. After purchasing a "new" PSE Firestorm Lite bow 2 years ago, I too had to change and go to a Mathews.
The bow I got was the Mathews SwitchbackXT, and I now wonder why it took so long to get one. It is by far the quietest bow I have ever shot, it's very forgiving and extremely accurate as well as fast.
Have heard good things about Hoyt's, Bowtech and others but the last couple of years alot of people are swithching over to Mathews bows.
If you are like me and watch numerous hunting videos prior to hunting season, you will see that most professional hunters are using a Mathews.