HuntingNet.com Forums - View Single Post - Healthy herd myth
View Single Post
Old 08-03-2007 | 07:44 PM
  #89  
Germ's Avatar
Germ
Boone & Crockett
 
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 11,682
Likes: 0
From: Michigan/Ohio
Default RE: Healthy herd myth

You said they died in the winter............can you prove that if you had fewer deer that the same number would not have died??.......or that if they had only shot fewer young bucks it could have been avoided??
Again you got bucks of your brain. The issue in the UP had to do with shooting to few does Not talking bucks here. As soon as QDM is mention bucks come to mind. Atlas does, does, does think does here. What led to the crash was a serious of events. Being NY does not bait or feed you guys are in way better shape. Our herd was dependant on us feeding them through the winter. In 95 feeding was banned due to TB.Now an over populated herd was left on its own. They destroyed the deer yards, and to this day have not recovered to what they where.

Can you prove this statement??
Yes I can Ask any hunter in the UP, need some names and numbers?

Wanting to preserve your freedom to hunt as you wish is selfish??
Nice try



Then Germ should do everything he can to go get one...........and not expect or insist that everyone else help Germ accomplish a goal that is Germ's goal.
Where have I ask? Hell I hunt with Uncle Trigger, LOL

Would you say a 700 lb man is healthier then a 180 lb man (same height and age) ??
Rabbits or humans, lets stick to deer. Ask someone else your loaded questions. Just so you know we are talking about whitetails, here is a picture of one so you know

Germ is offline  
Reply