I'm on the Davidmil side of the fence. Unless you are lucky or buying from a box store, most bows will have been shot before. I personnally like the fact that others have tested a bow out beforeI shoot it. Any flaws are found and I can see if that particular bow or model has any wear points that I don't like. As long as the bow isn't beat up, I'd take it. You, the proshop, and others have a different idea of what is "new." Looks like a classic look of lack of communication between you and the proshop. We have all learned the hard way that we need to communicate our thoughts and questions better. You can be upset with the proshop if you want to be, but some of the blame also lies with you and not letting the proshop know your expectations. I have been in the same spot as you. Just that my purchase involved a vehicle and several thousand more dollars.