I shot the black ice right before I purchased my guardian. Personally I loved the bow (although not as much as the guardian). It felt light in my hand and I loved the draw cycle not to mention the fact that it has decent speed. As far as you're concerned all I can say is shoot one and see for yourself. What feels right for me may not necessarily feel right for you. Overall I think it's a fantasic bow and if the price is low enough it may be hard to pass up.