This is my first post so Hello to all. That said I think we are arguing over which is more 6 or 1/2 dozen. I prefer fixed broadheads but I am comfortable with them, other fellow hunters like mechanicals. It comes down to what works for you, in your years of tuning and preening your individual setups. My gold tip xt hunters with mx-4 heads wont shoot well in YOUR setups just like your Gold stalkers with rocket mechanicals wont shoot very well in my setup. I think we forget our past where there is undeniable evidence that many many animals were take with proper shot placement and simple points made of flint or quartz, on very simple bows.
Perhaps it just comes down to what works for YOU!