Great thread. Its nice to see bowhunters showing so much respect for the sport while being courteous to each other even when they disagree. Many fine points made on both sides of the question.

I could not dream of shooting 70 yards with accuracy, so its difficult for me to even imagine the shot. Never hunted caribou either.

So basically I don't have an opinion, but I agree with everyone. He should never do it under any circumstances because its too risky but he can do it, because he can do it.<img src=icon_smile_big.gif border=0 align=middle>

I will say that I think Babe Winkleman Outdoors is a show that should stick to fishing.