GMMAT,
The question wasn't directed at you. Your opening question was a simple one and, personally, I think you have a great idea. The question was directed more at those who seem to be firmly opposed to the idea. It is labeled as a "Deer Hunting Contest", right?
Of course there's nothing wrong with competition. We're all competitive to some extent. I'd love to shoot a 3D tournament someday soon, and I'd probably enjoy being in this contest. I was just curious about how strongly some people felt about this. For me, when a competition turns serious, it's no longer an enjoyable experience. Again, that's just my opinion. There's absolutely nothing wrong with enjoying serious competition either. It's just not for me. That's why I asked.