I know this wasn't a choice, but, I bought an 835 Ulti-Mag for around $430.00. Holds the 3 1/2" shells, and some come with 3 different choke tubes. Mine also came with a sling. I bought a 870 Express, 20 gauge, with a 21" barrel for my wife. Had her camo it out. It has killed many turkeys in the last 5 years. I like carrying it when I have to hunt back-up when I take someone out to call for them. But, the Ulti-Mag will really reach out and touch'em if you get the right choke for it! Kicks a little, but I have yet to feel it when I am lined up on a big tom!