I am not trying to open up a can of worms here, would it make a difference if he was in a treestand? or if the deer had a huge rack? What if he was a new bowhunter and that was his first deer? (BE PROUD OF WHAT YOU SHOOT) Personally, I would not take a shot like that,but if he was legal....and had the proper tags, other than the fact that it was a young deer its still meat in the freezer. The shot was just about perfect. When we go into the woods with our bows, we are not there to pick dandelions, and thats pretty much the same sight anyone of has when the arrow hits its mark. Just seems like bowhunters slapping each other for what we do.