Well I hope that the two could agree and work it out but I know in todays world that is almost impossible. But I believe that the first guy to make the fatal shot should be legaly intittled to the deer. I don't know if there are any laws regarding that.

I know my dad several years ago shot a real nice 10 point and made a lethal shot but the buck ran and went over some railroad tracks. My dad track the deer and found it on the other side of the tracks but two guys were already gutting the buck and claiming it was theirs. What do you do when they are there with loaded handguns. A deer is just not worth someones life so dad let them have it. If someone is that determined I would let them have it.