Yes, I would pass. First thing I look for is inside spread. I want 20" and above. Next is the tine size and mass. These ares my standards in my choice hunting places. Some of the places here in NC I may lower them but lately those standards are paying off because we have been seeing more and more 18" spread deer. Later in the year, yes I may shoot him. For those who ask why, the big boy may show at anytime during the rut. So it's better to wait.