I had a nice buck come to my rattle bag tonight within 5 minutes. He was going to circle downwind and out of range so even though he was in sight (40 yards or so) i decided to gently hit the bag again and gave one short quiet grunt and he turned my way. I got off a nice broadside shot at about 25 yards but cliped a tiny twig and ended up killing a tree instead of the buck. Round one..deer 1, hunter 0, to be continued.