I have 2 Reflexes, a Buckskin and Timberwolf. I like them both but the Timberwolf is much nicer. I never shot the Highlander but I've shot all the new Fred Bears and they seemed like good bows also. The owner ofthe shop sells them all but he told me if anything ever needed parts he could get Reflex parts in just a few days but Fred Bear usually takes 4 to 6 weeks to get anything in. I would suggest shooting them some more if you can, that will make your decision.