I don't have 3 different brands but I do have 2. I also have a Moultrie 200 and I have 2 cuddebacks. If you have the money to spend I would say get the cuddeback you won't be sorry. The Moultrie is ok it takes decent picture especially in day light but, it is slow on trigger speed and it goes through batteries like crazy. If you decide to get a Moultrie I would say buy the rechargeable battery kit for it as well. In comparison the cuddeback batteries will last a good month and half to two months or more even. Where as the Moultrie it only last 2 weeks if your lucky. Good luck with what ever you decide on.