hold on if I am reading this right,what you are saying they offer a buck to you with thier tag on it not your's so there fore you would still have your 2nd tag left,I dont see the problem with it,To be truthfull though I would take the deer but I would let them know I was going to give it to some who could really use it,I think everyone here read this like I did the first time thinking that if they took the buck then they would be done.