RE: Horn Hunter or Badlands?
Haven't had my hands on a horn hunter, but I have the superday and it's great. Last season was my first with it, and it's held up very well. Quiet, and holds more than I take with me. I really like the fact that it's got the lifetime warranty so I never have to worry about ripping it or being out the considerable amount that they cost if it fails. Their customer service is pretty good too. I ended up having some pine sap drip down into the main zipper and it was sticking pretty bad. I contacted the company via email, and got a response within a day as to what they recommended for cleaning it out. I just looked at the horn hunter online...looking at the features it looks very good as well...for me it would be a tossup.