RE: Timberwolf Taxidermy I need info please help
You may have lost your cape, but unless something catastrophic happened he should still have your horns.
My suggestion would be to show up at his place and without shouting or yelling, ask for your antlers back. Explain they mean a lot to you and you understand he's been through a rough time. Offer to split the difference of your deposit, and if he gives you $100 back and the antlers you'll drop your civil case.
In this situation, you lost that $200 2 + years ago so it shouldn't sting as bad. If you could get $50 out of him I think you'd be lucky. The key is the antlers!
This happened to a buddy of mine and we did exactly the same thing. At first, he wasn't to cooperative. But since he wanted his boat back pretty bad, we got the deposit and antlers back.