Between the two you've listed , I'd opt for the Burris Fullfield II. I'm not a Simmons fan and I have a Fullfield II in 4.5-14x40 that's a nice scope. At the risk of complicating matters, there's also the Nikon Buckmasters series of scopes around the $200 mark. I actually prefer Leupold or Nikon scopes to Burris or Simmons, but that's just my two cents.