if you have both...do what maytom suggested...use both...if your looking to buy one over the other....the feeding hen would be a better choice i think...it may limit your calling to the hens docile vocals tho....soft purrs, yelpsand clucks...but clucks, yelpsand purrs DO bring in the toms..an alert hen deke might make the tom hang up out there...he gobbles and expects the hen to come to him...at least the feeding hen might seem less interested in breeding