Not sure, but sounds like you are new to archery. NO offense, I just assume that since it appears you are buying different gear as well. If im wrong, im sorry for the assumption. With this assumption, Id go with the compound. Its easier to learn. If you are not new, and looking for a new challange, Id go with the recurve. I shot all bows, and find hunting with a recurve or long bow is much more challenging. The first traditional kill is by far the most exciting.

I love compounds, but have as great of a love for traditionals.