I'll try and give you something-

First off what's wrong with the Goldtip Xt's?
are they not flying right? are there quality issue's?

A lot of people shoot Goldtip Xt's and like'em plenty.
Is there a possibly a spine issue your fighting?

As for myself I'm fond of the beman arrows. Black ICS hunters to be exact.

I'm not too sure there are any BAD arrows out there, get the spine right for your set-up and you should be shootin' just fine.