Huntingbry I agree with what you say so far I also have looked at nj. regulation per the link provided below and I also believe that his area is an earn a buck area but I will know for sure in a day or so also I have sent an e-mail to the NJ. fgw about this issue. I do however strongly disagree with you on one thing you said that you could understand if he shot the the deer by mistake well thats just as bad as flat out poaching a deer I know I have said it before on here but rule #1 when hunting absolutly positivly with out a doubt IDENTIFY YOUR TARGET BEFORE SHOOTING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Even if he did shoot it by mistake it is still ILLEGAL. 6pointsika I never said trock was a poacher or that his deer was illegal but I am questioning what is going and I find it extreamly wierd that all the sudden trock and his friend Bowdaddy have gotten quiet when people started to question his actions. If someone here was questioning me like this I would try to prove that I was in no way wrong. Such as taking a pic of my tags for the bucks or simply explaining the law in his area. Trock I realy honestly hope that it was on the up and up.