I think a lot of guys would be lying if they said they would pass on a 180inch buck because they didn't meet the earn a buck rule. We all try to play by the rules, but even the guys who are hired to enforce the rules break them. Calling the guy a scumbag is a little much. Stupid, for having a big mouth is a little more accurate. I don't condone breaking the law, but I would be lying if I said I wouldn't shoot a buck of a lifetime because of a silly earn a buck rule. Lucky for me I don't need to shoot a doe before I can shoot a buck in the zones I hunt.