What I do when house breaking is to get them out as soon as they wake up, and cut the water off at around 5 or 6pm, air after each meal, air twice before bed, and what I have seen work th egreatest, is when the dog goes to the bathroom, make that the biggest thing in the world, like woo hoo alright, what this is, is a praise for what has happened, and in your voice and hand clapping is excitement on a good thing. I have had dogs go back to the same area, for quite a while just for the praise that wa recived. Watch the dog to, you see when they start acting little goofy, shoot them out. Shut the toilet bowls to, no sneaking water. Thanks Jonesy