I voted NO. I have seen some real small bucks make some pretty agressive sized scrapes. Only to be followed and hit by a monster. I watched one small 6 pointer id say 6inch inside spread make a scrape 3 feet in diameter this year. I was very impressed how large the scrape was and how agressive he was when he made it. He meant business. Shortly after he left a big 11 came in and made it twice as big. I wish I had taken pictures of this scrape it was just massive and hit regularly by the two bucks. I couldnt get a shot at the 11.