HuntingNet.com Forums - View Single Post - ny p&y buck 8 pter 128.5 in, deer we couldnt find thread,found!!!
Old 12-08-2005 | 11:01 AM
  #55  
extreme1's Avatar
extreme1
Nontypical Buck
 
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 2,107
Likes: 0
From: Ontario,Canada
Default RE: ny p&y buck 8 pter 128.5 in, deer we couldnt find thread,found!!!

O.K this is the original story

[quote]











im sick,cant find an 8pter,unreal story - 11/13/2005 6:20:17 PM








showPicture("11/13/2005 6:20:17 PM",0,0,0,1293330,19)


monsterbuckland

titleAndStar(256,0,false,false,"","")
Rack Buck


[align=center][/align]
Posts: 256
Joined: 2/12/2003
From: latham,ny,usa
Status: offline
my friend had a sweet 8 come in, shot it @ 4 yrds straight down and threw it bled great first 30 yards and beds down,this is 7 am,,,,, i mean alotta blood not drops , piles,,, then beds, gets up goes 30 yards beds again,gets up 20 yrds beds again behind a tree and not visible and seemed to be dying,,,, all 3 beds had a basketball size blood stain, so he waits 2 hours and gets out and starts the search, the thing got up and took off, he left and called me and another and we went to get it, yeah right! we had blood 500 yards away, you know drops and then it jumped a downed tree and there was a puddle, like a glass full of blood in one spot then 2 more drops in 10 yards then nothing, i mean nothing at all, we spent 5 hours out there and no deer! makes me sick! what would you do??
And this is his new post








ny p&y buck 8 pter 128.5 in, deer we couldnt find threa... - 11/24/2005 3:13:59 PM








showPicture("11/24/2005 3:13:59 PM",0,0,0,1308982,19)


monsterbuckland

titleAndStar(256,0,false,false,"","")
Rack Buck


[align=center][/align]
Posts: 256
Joined: 2/12/2003
From: latham,ny,usa
Status: offline
i wrote a thread a few weeks ago about an 8pter my friend shot and it bled like crazy but we couldnt find it! well he found it! heres a pic, scores 128.5 typical as well!

http://home.nycap.rr.com/crazydog/images/burkee2005eightpter.jpg


holy! what is this judge judy! im not lying! it wasnt 2 weeks it was like 5-6 days and yes it was very cold and thats the truth! yes the animals got at it but luckily there was that left and about the score there wizards,,,,, the guy is an official scorer that shot it, the pic does it no justice its really thick and a 17 in inside spread! so believe or not those are the facts! it will be in the p&y book! and for this area in ny, thats a slammer! we dont have 190's running around because its the suburbs and theres no farms still working so no real good food!
I have to agree with the others on this thread.You posted your first entry on the 13th of november.Then you come here on the 24th of november and say you found your deer.Thats 11 days later,close enough to 2 weeks.I dought the deer was in that good of shape even after5-6 days as you say.Coyotes,ravens and animals in general would have lived off the deer carcas till it was all gone.Especially with snow on the ground and getting cold.
I highly dought that the eyes would have been intact,let alone still have a glare in them.They should have been dried out and caved in.The blood also looks to fresh to me as well.Its all just a little to fishy for me.
Do you have a pic of the whole deer,the one with the arrow going straight down through him.?Only pic I see is a head shot with glazing eyes and fresh blood.I truly believe this deer is either someone elses fresh kill or yourbuds saying you recovered it to get everyone off your back about not recovering it.
I am not judging the score of the deer because pics can be deceiving.

If in fact this deer was laying dead for5-6 days,and it is in the shape the pic describes then I truely appologise for coming across to strong,but it just looks to fishy to me.
Congrats to who ever shot him,he looks to be a nice 7 pointer

" />

Here is a pic of him again so everyone dosnt have to scrool back to page one




extreme1 is offline  
Reply