Currently in the market for new arrows (to be an xmas gift) so doing lots of looking. However, I agree with Jeff, accuracy is most important. With a good hit I think I'll penetrate any whitetail on the planet with my current bow, regardless of the arrow or broadhead chosen, but I want the straightest most accurate arrows around. I'm currently wrestling with staying light or going mid-heavy.

Jeff, how durable are the acc's compared to the current ic carbons? One thing I like about all carbons, for me they have been very durable. I like not having to buy new arrows because they bent coming into or out of a target or deer.