Kevin,
You are right to a point that biologists know better, BUT..
Does the fact that the Game Commission issues excess tags in an area that has few deer to begin with, obligate every hunter to buy those tags and be obligated to fill them all regardless of ability or want? We have butchered this whole issue to death in PA. There are areas in PA that make no sense at all as far as deer management. All I was proposing is, those folks who complain of seeing ZERO deer on most outings in an area that they enjoy hunting, should be very thoughtful and deliberate in the amount of deer they kill there.....just makes COMMON sense.