442deer I agree with you 100% 4 1\2 year old deer young???? The only place that a 4 1|2 year old deer needs more time to grow must be Texas. In iowa 4 1\2 year old deer is a true trophy. Stillhunt04 I think they are both nice bucks. I would choose the second buck, but only if he got to me first.LOL TXhighrack. If these are so small, post up some picks of the Texas Trophys you have bagged!?!?