buckeye, I have used these scents with the following results:

Buck Fever Synthetics "Pre/Post Rut"
Works very well for mock scrapes or to spice up an active scrape.

Buck Fever Synthetics "BF Rut"
Used it for licking branch and scrape, seems to work well or could just have been the pre/post rut already there. I couldn't tell.

Buck Fever Synthetics "BF Gland"
I know you didn't have it listed.
Used it for some rubs. I don't know how effective it was since I didn't have a trail cam watching the trees. I did see some bucks coming from the direction of the mock rub line I made so maybe it worked. Also used it on some licking branches.

Code Blue "WhiteTail Buck Urine"
Used on some scrapes. Couldn't tell a difference.

Wildlife Research Center "Active Scrape"
I use this stuff every year in my drippers. Always seems to work well right at the start of and during the rut. Doesn't work well before the rut.

As far as decoying, the only stuff I used was the BF RUT and BF Gland on my decoy. I didn't see anything that day. Probably was just a bad day or maybe they winded me. I didn't use it again since it was such a pain to carry everything into the woods on public land.

On a side note, that is like $60 worth of Code Blue! Did you at least try to get the same numbered buck? I wonder if they really do that or if they just write that on the bottles?