RE: Would like some input on shotguns
Have you looked at the Browning BPS?
They are great shot guns. I have a BPS stalker in 3.5''. I would have to say b/t it and my Remington 700, they are the most reliable guns in my safe.
I also agree that a 3.5'' isn't something that you have to have, but I like it.
They also have the BPS in 3'' models.
If you have your mind set on the ones you have listed, its kinda hard to make a suggestion b/c all are good guns, but you are also comparing a pump to an auto.
I wouldn't say that you would go wrong with either on your list. However, I would strongly encourage you to go take a look at a BPS if you want a pump.
Also something to keep in mind. Many people ask about guns and make a decision based on other peoples suggestions and/or advice w/o even picking up the gun first. BAD IDEA. Everyone is different. Try the gun to make sure it fits your body b/c I assure you that nothing is worse than spending that much money on a gun that isn't comfortable to shoot.