I will be hunting Stuyvesant Farm for the muzzleloader and rifle season this year. Several of my hunting buddies have been in the past and they are on cloud nine when they come back. I am very excited to go and I will let you know how my experience is if you haven't gone yourself already.
I will be doing the Bow hunt next year.
For other hunts I would highly recommend Brady Ranch in Florida for Axis deer. It has competitive rates and trophy quality animals. You can spend as little or as much as you want depending on your taste. The accomodations are comfortable, the people are very hospitable, and the food is unbelievable, plus you will see exotic animals from all over the world. Check out their website at bradyranch.com. Oh by the way their is a ranch down the road that does Wild Boar hunts if you want to mix it up a little.

-Brandon