I would get the SBE II, I like it 10 times better than the Extreama. The comfort tec stock reduces recoil a lot and the grips are slimmer. The extreama feels like you are holding a club not a shotgun. The SBE II action also feels smoother to me and it has the larger trigger guard for gloves. Right now I am using a Nova, but when I can aford it I will be upgrading to a SBE II.