Ryan,

I had the same exact scenario last spring. I had worked an area the day before, and slipped in around 10:30. I hit the calls, and was answered within minutes by a gobble. Within 5 minutes, there stood three birds, looking identical.

Except the one in front had a longer beard. They never went into strut, so I'll never know...

Having not punched a tag last year, though, I probably shoulda' pulled the trigger, because I also no longer hunt that property...